For 2024 the aim remains to post a review at least every other Friday and to complete the Bookpacking reading journey.

03 July 2012

The Sisters Brothers by Patrick DeWitt


The journey



Part of the America 1850 reading journey



How it got on the shelf



My sister and I have this unspoken 20 year tradition whereby when December comes the question is not what to buy him/her for Christmas, but which book should I buy him/her.  The difficulty is choosing one unlikely to have been read previously, and so one way to go is for a recently published paperback and hope you are one step ahead of your sibling.  The minor miracle is that we have so far avoided in any year swapping the very same book.



The 2011 arrival was The Sisters Brothers.  Intriguingly titled with an eye catching cover (two gunmen silhouetted against a rising moon - but symbolic to me of a skull) I had fondled it once or twice in Waterstones, so was very pleased to unwrap it on Christmas morning.



The Review



Starting in Oregon City in 1851, two hired gunslingers Eli and Charlie Sisters, set off on their latest assignment, requiring a journey to California in pursuit of their mark.



Their mission is narrated by Eli, in language that has a period feel and displays a sensitivity that belies his profession.  In truth it is his brother who is the natural born killer, and Eli is constantly torn between his own sensibilities and his loyalty to the hard as nails Charlie.



The brothers’ complex relationship is splendidly explored and the pioneer west is vividly depicted showing a bizarre mixture of brutality, comedy and humanity. Episodes along the way are described with cinematic clarity, whether in a saloon cum whorehouse, in gold crazy San Francisco, or at the final showdown.



The setting is fascinating, and the story is engaging, but it is the contrasting characters of Eli & Charlie and their complex, changing relationship that gives the book its tremendous appeal.  You have to feel for Eli and through him you grow to care for his brother, so that eventually you find yourself rooting happily for what is, at the end of the day, a murderous gang.



A must read.

No comments:

Post a Comment