The game is football, association football
to be clear, and the English game to be specific. In seven extended essays
Goldblatt surveys the game as it stands in 2014, placing it in the context of
its own history and more interestingly as a mirror reflecting wider social
change.
Thus he argues how the moneyed Premiership
has emerged inevitably from globalisation and deregulation; and describes how the
consequent commercialisation of the match day experience as a packaged product has
undermined but not yet destroyed the deep-seated tribal passions.
The third essay provides a whistle-stop tour
of English clubs, region by region, concentrating on relationships between the
clubs and their communities; too brief to be anything but an entertaining
aide-memoire to those already familiar with their football, and in my view too
superficial in dismissing owners, managers and players as mainly useless.
Later the ‘national’ concept of the English
game is discussed relative to the other ‘home nations’ (contrast is drawn to
other sports where it is the UK or Great Britain that represents national
feeling); and the governance of the game gets a good pounding for its
amateurishness and unpreparedness for the modern world.
Chapters on race and gender complete the
book, setting out how attitudes within the game have both reacted to and shaped
changing social norms. These may be the most interesting for general readers,
or those more interested in sociology than football.
The mix of football and sociology works
well, but the articulate Goldblatt’s prose makes no concessions to those who
follow their sport in the Mail or the Mirror - this is more for Guardian
readers out there. The points are well made, evidence is painstakingly
referenced, and he clearly has mastery of his subject; but he mainly sets out
the problems without offering suggested solutions.
An academic and though-provoking read for
those with a sociological interest, delivering a comprehensive version of what
its subtitle promises: “the making and meaning of English football”.
No comments:
Post a Comment